Financial sextortion cases are on the rise
Every day, dozens of people contact PAPS with inquiries about people they met on social media (such as Instagram or language exchange apps) demanding money (or threatening them) using sexual images or videos of them.
It has also become an international problem as a manualized criminal act known as "financial sextortion."
To counter this intimidation technique, we suggest the following:
According to UN Special Rapporteur Joy Ngozi Ezeilo (2007), the majority of trafficking in persons in Japan is for the purpose of prostitution and other forms of sexual exploitation, that a comprehensive and holistic approach "5 Ps" and "3 Rs" are essential as a strategic foundation to address this situation, especially trafficking in persons (sexual exploitation) of women and children.
PAPS works on the basis of these eight strategic foundations, which are as follows.
What is comprehensive support?
What is comprehensive support?
Block the opponent
Leave group chat
Set your account as private
Change your account username
What is comprehensive support?
For iPhone
Messages app → View chat history → Tap the other person's phone number or email address → Block this caller
iPhone Settings (gear icon) → Messages → Turn off iMessage.
iPhone Settings (gear icon) → Turn off FaceTime
Even if you turn off iMessage, you can still receive SMS. Please also try the " Block SMS from overseas " procedure below.
What is comprehensive support?
Block someone (long press on their username)
Settings → Friends → Turn off "Auto-add friends" and "Allow friends to add you"
Settings → Profile → Turn off "Allow adding friends by ID"
If you have sent your own QR code, display your My QR code and press the "Update" button at the bottom.
What is comprehensive support?
The main ones used are Telegram, WhatsApp, Twitter, CakaoTalk, etc. They may also ask you to install apps from non-official stores.
Cancel or delete your app account
Uninstall the app
If the threats continue and you don't know what to do, please contact Pappus' advice centre or report it to the police.
How to deal with this issue (common)
What is comprehensive support?
Image is for illustrative purposes only
In some cases, the scammer may send you a screen capture of the scene immediately after sending a sexual image, but in many cases the image is not sent and the scammer may cancel the image immediately after sending it.
Instagram does not allow you to send images directly to private accounts.
Sextortion is a special type of fraud that aims to rapidly increase your own anxiety and make you pay money to escape from that anxiety, but it is not intended to send images to a third party.
If you are contacted by an acquaintance or friend who has actually received the email, and you are currently downloading and saving the videos or images that are threatening you, we recommend that you extract digital fingerprints from the sexual images and register them with StopNCII/Takeitdown, which will prevent them from being posted or spread on Instagram or other social media.
StopNCII does not have a Japanese version, but you can register using the translation function of your browser.
What is comprehensive support?
For damage control (to keep damage to a minimum),
Some people give the following explanation to those who receive sexual images:
He is currently being threatened after deepfake porn was created.
She has been a victim of revenge porn and is currently being threatened.
I am being threatened with sextortion.
Some people have announced in advance that they would like to be notified if they receive suspicious images on Instagram stories. I think these are effective ways to reduce your own anxiety.
If you do not have any sexual images on hand, we recommend that you obtain them from the person who sent you the images and register with STOPNCII and Takeitdown as mentioned above.
What is comprehensive support?
"Sextortion" is a compound word that combines "Sex" and "Extortion" and means sexual blackmail or threat. For example, a person who has become close to the victim online through SNS etc. may ask them to "send sexual photos" or "show each other masturbation on a video call", and they are tricked into sending photos of their face along with sexual parts of their body or underwear, or in the case of a video call, they are tricked into showing it in real time. At that time, the other party saves the images and videos sent, and takes (secretly takes) pictures of the situation when answering the video call without consent. After that, they threaten to "expose on the Internet" not only the saved (taken) images and videos, but also the sexual exchanges that have been conducted by text. Even if the victim complies with the other party's demands, it is a criminal act that repeatedly makes unreasonable demands and threats to corner the victim. Many victims feel guilty about having sent sexual images and videos, and are unable to talk to anyone, which leads to mental cornering and isolation.
The situation is even more serious for children under the age of 18 who have never been in contact with malicious people or been deceived by others. They are afraid of disappointing their parents by being "a child who would do such a thing," so they often give up and do as the perpetrator tells them, without being able to talk to anyone. In fact, some children who have been connected to our organization were unable to confide in anyone, and their parents only found out after they attempted suicide. Trafficking of children under the age of 18 is defined as "the acquisition, transportation, transfer, harboring, or receipt of a child for the purpose of exploitation" (Article 3 of the Protocol to the United Nations Convention against Transnational Organized Crime). Sextortion victims receive sexual images and videos from children for the purpose of sexual exploitation, and can be said to be a form of human trafficking. The US Department of Defense has already taken up sextortion as the theme for Human Trafficking Prevention Month in January 2023.
Number of Sextortion Victims
Two Types of Sextortion
There are two main types of sextortion:
The first is sextortion for the purpose of "domination."
Women are especially vulnerable to this, and perpetrators exploit their romantic feelings for the victim by making them send videos of themselves masturbating or take photos or videos during sexual intercourse. Then, after the relationship ends, they use those videos or photos to threaten them, demanding that they "send more sexual images," "pay back the money we spent during the relationship," or "let's go out again."
If you are a victim, it is important for you to assert your rights. For example, it is effective to inform the perpetrator that providing sexual images to a third party is a crime and subject to criminal punishment. In addition, once you have informed them of your rights, it is also important not to have any further exchanges with the perpetrator. If you continue to reply, the other person may misunderstand that there is still room for threats or that they have feelings for you. If the victim is under 16 years old, it will be a crime of requesting the transmission of sexual images, and if a child under 18 sends sexual images, it will be a crime of aiding and abetting the Child Pornography Prohibition Act (Act on the Regulation and Punishment of Acts Related to Child Prostitution and Child Pornography, and the Protection of Children, etc.). It is also important to consult the police early. If you are over 18 years old, it may be a crime of taking pictures without consent (voyeurism), and if you actually spread it, it may be a violation of the Revenge Porn Prevention Act (Act on the Prevention of Damage Caused by the Provision of Private Sexual Image Records, etc.).
Many victims tend to choose to do nothing for fear that the situation will worsen, but this will only make the situation worse. By exercising your rights, you will increase the chances of preventing the perpetrator from committing the crime. Because victims have legal protection, they actually have the balls to turn the situation around. If you notify the other party of this, they will be overcome with anxiety and fear that they may be arrested, and the positions of victim and perpetrator will suddenly be reversed.
The second is sextortion for financial gain.
Men are especially vulnerable to this, and perpetrators approach their victims on social media, build trust through one-on-one interactions, and get them to send sexual images. If it's a video call, the perpetrator will secretly record the victim naked when the woman asks them to "show her body," and threaten them by demanding that they pay money if they don't want the images or videos to be sent to the victim's social media followers. Perpetrators maximize the victim's anxiety, for example, by counting down "20 seconds left...10 seconds to spread," driving the victim into fear. The victim pays the money, desperate to escape that fear. Perpetrators may also ask for the victim's social media accounts and phone numbers other than Instagram in case they are blocked.
The important thing to remember here is that if you pay money, they will not delete the account. If you pay money even once, the criminal will consider you a "gullible person" and will continue to threaten you. It is important to never pay money, block the criminal on social media as soon as possible, and contact the police, a trusted person, or a support organization.
The increase in sextortion cases is due to the current situation where "taking sexual photos and videos" has become common among young people. In this situation, in order to prevent victimization and perpetration, it is important to spread awareness that asking "Can I take sexual photos or videos?" is itself digital sexual violence.
How financial sextortion perpetrators use
We have summarized the methods used by perpetrators in actual sextortion cases.
The Zeigarnik effect (mere exposure effect)
This is the effect that even if you were not interested in something at first, your liking and impression of it will increase if you are repeatedly exposed to a specific person in a short period of time. In the case of sextortion, it is said that the Zeigarnik effect is more likely to occur in DMs (one-on-one exchanges) on social media.
01
Foot in the Door
It is the psychology of getting someone to accept small requests first, then gradually make bigger requests, and finally get them to accept the desired request. For example, if you send a sexual image once, you will not be able to refuse the next time, and you may be asked for even more extreme images. This is also called "step-by-step requests."
03
Evoking fear
The amygdala, a part of the brain, plays a major role in emotions such as excitement, fear, and anxiety. The amygdala plays a central role in controlling emotions, and when you are excited, adrenaline is secreted in the body, your breathing and heart rate speed up, and you sweat. This is to prepare for the "face or run" decision. In sextortion, feeling fear while sexually excited can lead to misjudgment of the brain.
05
Resolving cognitive dissonance
To reduce feelings of guilt, people choose a passive solution. They tell themselves that paying the money will prevent the worst from happening, that it is the price of learning, and so they pay the money, believing that "paying the money" will make things easier for them.
If the other person has a weakness, you will not be able to accept the fact that it is a scam and will end up handing over the money as they ask. This psychological mechanism of trying to resolve the discomfort caused by cognitive dissonance distorts your judgment.
07
Foot in the door
Financial sextortion is a method in which the victim first transfers a small amount (e.g., 20,000 yen) and then gradually increases the amount demanded. After the initial payment, the victim threatens to demand more money, saying that the footage is stored on a computer or cloud, or that the footage is also recorded on another smartphone. In this way, the victim ends up with a large amount of debt. Be careful.
09
The principle of reciprocity
When you receive an image from someone, you feel obligated to send an image in return. With sextortion, if someone sends you sexually explicit photos or strips off during a video call, you feel obligated to do the same.
02
Normalcy bias → causes panic
Normalcy bias is a psychological reaction that makes people believe that "it's okay" even in a crisis situation. If this bias is strong during a disaster such as an earthquake, people may be late in escaping or responding, which can lead to greater damage. In the case of men who are victims of sextortion, there is a social background in which men do not believe that sexual photos or videos of men are threatening, and they are not aware that men can be victims, which can lead to panic when they are actually threatened.
04
No time to think
When the countdown begins, "20 seconds left... 10 seconds left to spread," people lose the time to think, and they end up believing what the perpetrator says and acting accordingly. This is a common tactic in many types of fraud. The aim is to make people anxious and take away their ability to make decisions.
06
Door in the face
This is a method of "overcharging, then giving in a little." If they can't pay 200,000 yen, I'll forgive them for 20,000 yen. In the case of young people who are victims of sextortion, the amount can be reduced to create a situation where they cannot refuse. In other cases, they may create a loan that does not exist and draw them in as a community of interest (an organization whose goal is the survival and well-being of the organization itself or its members).
08
Sunk Cost Bias (Concorde Effect)
In financial sextortion, the other party threatens to spread information if the money is not paid. Even if the victim knows they are being deceived, they may end up paying more money out of fear that the money they have already paid will go to waste. This is the psychology of "loss aversion." Therefore, it is important to make a calm judgment.
10
PAPS supports survivors of sexual exploitation and digital sexual violence.
Outreaching,
Providing a place to stay
-
Outreaching: A process in which social workers proactively reach out to those who need assistance but have not yet received it, by talking to them and providing information and support.
-
Removal Request: Requesting the removal of sexually explicit images on behalf of the person concerned.
-
Advocacy: Public relations, awareness - raising, policy advocacy, etc.